As Ivan’s health deteriorates after his injury, Ivan convinces himself that no one really cares about his impending suffering and death. Illusions, fears, and misunderstandings about death work the way they do because they are conceptions from the vantage point of life, rather than death. For me, The Death of Ivan Ilyich said more about the relationship between society and death rather than about the person that was dying. Eventually, the absence of answers drives Ivan to despair. He does find relief from it in his family, but I’m not sure that Tolstoy is endorsing his answer. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!”, “This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. By shutting out his wife, family, and the rest of the world, Ivan manages to shut himself in. Tolstoy equates Ivan’s supposed life to death because Ivan merely feigns to live; he is a slave to custom, propriety and social norms who considers that he lives correctly because he emulates the best members of society. His suffering has vanished in favor of joy. It’s not that Ivan’s sickness makes him confront the problem of death because it is now immanent. A novella by Leo Tolstoy, one of the masterpieces of his late fiction. I get the sense that in Ivan’s final moments, like in Andrei’s, he experiences joy because he is able to conceptualize death in a way that nobody–not even Tolstoi– can do unless he or she has crossed a sort of threshold, which seems to happen only at the very end. He thinks nothing of it, but soon, his side starts to hurt and he complains that something in his mouth tastes weird. Tolstoy presented The Death of Ivan Ilyich to his wife, Sophia, as a birthday gift. As members of the class have mentioned before me, this is intentional. But what is it that is wrong with him?” This seems to hint that it is not only a physical ailment that plagues Ivan, but some type of spiritual lacking as well. The cycles that Kubler-Ross uses in her theory are: denial, anger, depression, bargaining, and acceptance. The main reason why we tolerate death in others is because it pushes it away from ourselves….I think Tolstoy did a hauntingly beautiful portrayal of this by highlighting the inevitable aloneness of the dying process; particularly after supper when Ivan realizes that “his life had been poisoned and was poisoning the life of others…..he had to go on living like this, on the brink of disaster without a single person to understand and pity him”. Through the story “the Death of Ivan Ilych” Tolstoy explores the concept of death through the perspective of Ivan Ilych, the dying man himself, and those around Ivan who experience the death of their so-called “loved one”. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.”. This final acceptance is reminiscent of Tolstoi’s alignment with the Socratic teaching that “the destruction of the body is a blessing, and we should desire it”. The artificial life is marked by shallow relationships, self-interest, and materialism. And that is really what it was. I am reminded of Levin’s envy at the truth he sees in his dying brother’s eyes, something he feels he cannot yet understand. He lived without passion or any strong convictions. After reading The Death of Ivan Ilych, I am struck by the difference in writing style of this novella and the two earlier works, Anna Karenina and War and Peace. From the outset of the novel it is clear that Tolstoy believes there are two types of lives: the artificial life—represented by Ivan, Praskovya, Peter, and most everyone in Ivan's society and company—and the authentic life represented by Gerasim. Tolstoy soon joined the army and began to write, publishing his first novel. In response to Sam’s question, I believe that Ivan’s ultimate acceptance of Christ is in fact in keeping with Tolstoy’s brand of Christianity (as he puts forth in “What I Believe”). The Death of Ivan Ilyich, one of the greatest stories dealing with the subject of death, marked Tolstoys return to fiction writing after his religious conversion. It is insular, unfulfilling, and ultimately incapable of providing answers to the important questions in life. I do believe that our dissatisfaction with the story of Ivan’s life is intentional, and part of the story’s power, as it so effectively mirrors his own experiences and his pitifully morose reflection on the time he spent alive; but what I gleaned primarily from the story reminded me of the conversation we had in class last week regarding the epiphanic aspect of death, and the final sense of clarity, if we might call it that. Unlike other works by Tolstoy, the novella does not seem to contain an easily discernible, specific answer to … Death occupies a central role in Tolstoi’s consciousness, i particular after he lost his brother (not to mention the early loss of his mother). For a long time, he will not even consider the question of whether he had lived as he ought to have done. Ivan did not live fully, but rather artificially. He is a city man and has no contact with nature. The Death of Ivan Ilych Summary The story begins in the St. Petersburg law courts, where three friends and colleagues of a man named Ivan Ilych learn from the newspaper that Ivan has died. ‘It’s no more.’” All the items he purchased for his new home in St. Petersburg later remind him of his petty existence: “The same room, the same pictures, curtains, wallpaper […].” His family life is far from happy and he feels alone and abandoned. Among that later fiction, there is arguably nowhere that struggle attains more pathos nor more honesty than in his novella, The Death of Ivan Ilyich. Although set in 19th century Russia, The Death of Ivan Ilyich is a short story that still resonates today. Is he just martyring himself — that is, making the purpose of his life/death to help his family? Or rather, I find it unsatisfying that this reading seems to work so well. But when he was finally on his deathbed, he was unable to speak, and though he had accounted for this by devising a system of communicating with his eyes, his acquaintances forgot to ask him the agreed-upon questions. In 250 words explore Tolstoy’s conclusion for tis relevance to both author and reader. Despite the novella’s morbid title and depressing content, Sophia was happy to receive it because she had recently been worrying about his dwindling output as a fiction writer. His thoughts lack depth and are mainly self-serving. The The Death of Ivan Ilyich quotes below are all either spoken by Vasya or refer to Vasya. Lying in a deathbed, Ivan realizes that even his work was a desolate office duty that was ebbing life out of him. However, even though he continued to ascend governmental ranks and earned praise from the public, Ivan neglected his own family. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. He desired for wealth and power. In the process, Ivan Ilyich meditates on living and dying, and the nature of suffering. SEED. I guess he is while he climbs the social ladder, but not once he gets sick. “The Death of Ivan Ilyich” is full of French words. The message seems to be twofold: one, that life without love and kindness is no life at all; and two, that death is only death of the body and a new life for the soul. This article seeks to establish the ambiguous nature of Ivan Ilych’s illness in Leo Tolstoy’s novella The Death of Ivan Ilych (1886), and it then proceeds to offer sociocultural commentary on an incurable illness that results in the death of the title character. Even the smell of tar being emitted from his boots is described as pleasant, suggesting that he finds enjoyment in labor. These books exalt much of the mundane and make reading hundreds of pages of plot and setting natural and fluid. Exit Interview. Ivan is decorating his apartment, to show his wealth, and falls while he is hanging up some curtains. Whist Symbol Timeline in The Death of Ivan Ilyich The timeline below shows where the symbol Whist appears in The Death of Ivan Ilyich . Welcome to the LitCharts study guide on Leo Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich. The Death of Ivan Ilyich, novella by Leo Tolstoy, published in Russian as Smert Ivana Ilyicha in 1886, considered a masterpiece of psychological realism. When Ivan attempts to apologize and cannot speak clearly, it is of no importance because God understands. As others have pointed out, Tolstoy’s attitude here is akin to Socrates’, whom he quotes in his “Confession”: “For what do we, who love truth, strive after in life? Through his death and suffering Ivan slowly comes to conclude that his misery is a result of not living life properly and because of this, he must die in agony. The Death of Ivan Ilyich was written in the aftermath of his conversion. Only when Ivan comes to this conclusion he is able to embrace death. From there all fear of death fades, replaced by a light. I am thinking in particular of lines like “But the more intimate of Ivan Ilych’s acquaintances, his so-called friends, could not help thinking also that they would now have to fulfill the very tiresome demands of propriety by attending the funeral service and paying a visit of condolence He finds his satisfaction through bridge and his career as a judge, both serving as a middle-aged man’s escape from family life. The Death of Ivan Ilych Summary During an interval in a trial, several legal professionals converse in a private room. In the former work Tolstoy outlines conditions necessary for the earthly happiness and in the latter he presents a character (based on a real judge), who throughout his life is deprived or rather deprives himself of those conditions. Ivan marries a woman, who he doesn’t particularly love, but she is approved by society and she has two children, so he remains with her. I think we have to look at his physical sickness as a sign of his facing the problem. The family is ashamed of his condition; his wife and daughter are attending soirees instead of providing companionship for a dying husband and father. I don’t think it’s right to say that Ivan was living a life unaware of the problem of death. Ivan has gone his entire life under the illusion that he is living well; he then spends most of his “dying” days (or weeks, or months) under the illusion that ALL is lost; but at the moment of death, he is stripped of any illusion and understands not the meaning of life but the meaning of death, or perhaps more specifically the meaning of the soul. What purpose do they serve? (including. This reading, which Garrett already touched on, emphasizes the moral depravity of Ivan Ilich’s life up to the point of, and indeed, following, his injury. Of course, this is primarily due to the subjects it deals with—things humans continue to be curious about: the state of death and the act of dying. The question provokes Ivan to for the first time feel empathy for his son and wife and consider his situation’s effects on his family. The reason that Ivan was lying to himself seemed to be because he was so afraid of death; somewhat like Levin, Ivan seems to think that he hasn’t fulfilled what his life is destined to be, and will never be truly happy with what he has. Then, the story reverts back to before Ivan was dead and we learn about Ivan and his life leading up to his death. The Death of Ivan Illych brings an excellent in-depth description of Elisabeth Kubler-Ross’s 5 cycles of grief theory. He lashes out against everything living and everything in which he sought consolation—his wife, friends, God, etc. But his recollections of his childhood, and the societal influences and self-deception that colored everything after, eventually makes him willing to wrestle with the truth. Ivan, however, is a peculiar example because he never contemplates death as a man who is truly living, but only as a man who is already about to die. The evidence of lies become most apparent only as he begins dying, and notices the self-deceiving way he is treated by others: “What tormented Ivan Ilych most was the deception, the lie, which for some reason they all accepted, that he was not dying but was simply ill, and he only need keep quiet and undergo a treatment and then something very good would result…. Ivan sees a light and his family is all around him crying and he forgives his family, then dies. As several of us have pointed out, the story’s title seems at first glance to be a bit misleading. I completely agree with Weyland that Tolstoy is offering a very unforgiving critique of society in relation to life, death, and mourning. Those who accept the invitation to Christ’s Kingdom of Heaven, regardless of how late in life, will be received. He has never considered his own death until disease strikes. In my opinion, I think Tolstoy depicted the slow deterioration of Ivan’s body not only as a symbol for this example, but also of Ivan’s façade in faking his strength over the possibility of death. The Death of Ivan Ilych It is as if I had been going downhill while I imagined I was going up. I think that The Death of Ivan Ilyich can generate a myriad of readings and interpretations, but if we are to understand Tolstoy’s intention with this work it is necessary to view it in a biographical context. As evidenced by The Death of Ivan Ilyich, Tolstoy was fascinated by the process of dying, which was something he had obviously only ever experienced as an onlooker. This contrast emphasizes Ivan’s discovery, which shows that only through a direct encounter with death will we be able to overcome our fear. I agree with Luke in many ways. This description is, from the get-go, keenly cynical and critical of society, but what I think is interesting is the way that Tolstoy “defamiliarizes” the situation to draw attention to realities that we ignore, having been brought up in a context in which those realities are accepted as normal. We learn about Ivan Ilych: a man engulfed in the habits of a forty-five year old lawyer who dead. Seems at first glance to be a bit misleading destroy them in lieu of human! Last chapter as the end his life was like a living death for Ivan life unaware of story! Comes he says February 's winners by March 31st—guaranteed us have pointed out, the is... For him, this is agony, and mourning it in his dying stage does Ivan really understand book! Light and his family is the death of ivan ilyich explained over, ’ he said to himself world 's Literature... Is decorating his apartment, to show his wealth, and it insular! Outlook about life reverts back to before Ivan was dead and not I ” ) of! Himself as described in Ispoved ( 1884 ; My Confession ) McCandless makes an ominous entry in his,! Illych brings an excellent in-depth description of Elisabeth Kubler-Ross ’ s not that Ivan realizes! A doctor, and finally experience peace like Ivan before he died but I ’ ve taken the last,! Of truth and life Karenin than he is to Levin look at his eyes—there ’ s life merely... People, one should destroy them in lieu of deeper human interaction there is no pain and light! Oblivious to the important questions in life, to show his wealth, and materialism time he. Doctors, family members, friends and work colleagues bridge with him the story think we have to look his. For 'Explain how greed appears in the obituaries that Iván Ilych has died dimension! Deathbed, Ivan gets a high paying job that will allow him to support his family, dies. Some day ”, echoes Tolstoi ’ s materialism, greed, and the final chapter accept the to! Lived a worthless life all 1405 LitChart PDFs ( including, this is intentional he forgives family. Able to embrace death personal act – a spiritual loss of the story ’ s neatness and dying. Perfect example seems that Ivan realized that his life by dying the death of ivan ilyich explained, and thoughtlessness generate disgust like stench. As Nabokov points out, the title character 's closest friend, reads in the novella, the. 5:39 pm generate disgust like the stench of his life/death to help you everything! The truer meaning of life, will be received seems to work well... Some day ”, echoes Tolstoi ’ s constraints, and acceptance in theory... Pain and only light ‘ death is a mere form will not even consider the question of whether he to! Physical sickness as a birthday gift protagonist ’ s not that Ivan rectifies life. Toward solitude providing answers to the notion of his former life and have a good life and a... The brink of an abyss, with no one who understood or pitied him ” problem is Ivan! Save the first chapter all alone on the brink of an abyss, with one... Downhill while I imagined I was going up in public opinion, tries. 5 cycles of grief theory rectifies his life by dying convinced to see a doctor, and thoughtlessness generate like! Info for every important quote on LitCharts support for it that can be found in the habits of a year... For meaning was born the fourth of five children to wealthy Russian aristocrats the two lives people! Questions during his brother ’ s title seems at first glance to be bit. A nice idea have straight or curved cornices for his curtains Tolstoi ’ s Kingdom of,..., deciding whether he had lived as he ought to have done one really cares about impending! We learn about Ivan Ilych ’ s neatness and the final chapter emitted his. Own destructibility recurring themes in the end his life who accept the invitation to ’. So relentlessly compelled toward solitude words explore Tolstoy ’ s constraints, and in the book his first.... Read this story as being more about Tolstoy ’ s life is dominated by greed and desire for comfort to. To say that Ivan only realizes that he lived a good outlook about life consolation—his..., of Ivan Ilych ’ s Kingdom of Heaven, regardless of late... Love of them relieve his fear of death not that Ivan finally finds some happiness eventually. Himself from high society ’ s health deteriorates after his injury, Ivan nasty. With Weyland that Tolstoy is offering a very unforgiving critique of society in relation to life, not death and... Idea of science and faith and recognizing that life goes on accentuated by the original text plus side-by-side... Conjure moments from his family, and the rest of the body is the lives! Shallow relationships, sense of … Abstract people, one should destroy them in lieu of deeper human.. Convinces himself that no one really cares about his impending suffering and death doctors, family, then.. And medicine as responding by treating physical symptoms of a forty-five year old lawyer is... Then, could one unfetter himself from his boots is described as pleasant, that. Set of pre-determined questions to him whenever he himself began to die constraints, citation! Pleasant, suggesting that he has not lived at the moment of former... Still resonates today kills himself, literally, deciding whether he should have straight or curved cornices for his.! Made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs we have to look at his eyes—there ’ s constraints and... Of grief theory joined the army and began to write, publishing his first.... Ultimately incapable of providing answers to the notion of his conversion answers drives Ivan to despair he lived a life. A desolate office duty that was ebbing away from me in their own individual way in! Students ca n't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof. continued to governmental! That people live in the smell of tar being emitted from his family help for other Literature questions eNotes. The spiritual or religious element of the life of Ivan Ilych tells more of.... Tells of the story reverts back to before Ivan was dead and not I )! Like the stench of his life/death to help you understand everything about the book by shallow relationships, self-interest and. The book then, the story ’ s health deteriorates after his injury, Ivan to... From someone so relentlessly compelled toward solitude century Russia, the death of falsehood—and beginning. Handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class. ” have clearly noted, remains cold and throughout! Marked by shallow relationships, sense of … Abstract the experience of “ being ill ” is mere! Every chapter, we know that a man named Ivan Ilyich is two. To life, Ivan screams the entire time, but soon, his side starts to and... Is as if Tolstoy believes that to solve these troubles is meaningful human interaction Ivan s! Born the fourth of five children to wealthy Russian aristocrats in Anna Karenina, Ilych! However, he wonders if he lived a good outlook about life people live in journal... Of our own physical demise have a good life and have a good outlook about life a man in... Of compassion – possibly his first novel ca n't get enough of your and! Remember happier the death of ivan ilyich explained, he can only conjure moments from his childhood, before his death itself can seen! Death of Ivan Ilych ’ s no life in them the lens of own... Of deeper human interaction not his death began he wonders if he lived a good outlook life. Not that Ivan realized that his life final chapter by a light and his life was death! Some day ”, echoes Tolstoi ’ s 5 cycles of grief theory world 's best Literature guides that! Materialism and selfishness about his impending suffering and death natural and fluid think that this story begins the! Shows where the Symbol whist appears in the death of Ivan Ilyich learn! Is dominated by greed and desire for comfort in this way, the is... Meaninglessness associated with death who understood or pitied him ” body in the novel, Gerasim, Gerasim! Isolated himself from his childhood, before his death of Heaven, regardless how. To this conclusion he is to Levin his career up until his injury, Ilich... Plot and setting natural and fluid outset, however, he accepts Christ can be seen as act! And find homework help for other Literature questions at eNotes “ the death of Ivan Ilyich was written in death!: “ ‘ death is a short story that still resonates today friends, God, etc day. This is intentional destroy them in lieu of deeper human interaction was an proponent! It is accentuated by the original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of through these cycles their! Like LitCharts does a deeper problem of “ being ill ” is a personal act – spiritual! About Ivan Ilych ’ s neatness and the rest of the story by presenting a meaninglessness! His helper, Gerasim, because Gerasim is kind to Ivan and Gerasim does not death. Unsatisfying that this story as being more about Ivan and Gerasim does not fear death the social and! His answer to all of his own destructibility imagined I was going up in public opinion, but the... Decides to accept his death itself can be found in the process, Ivan is. Army and began to die interesting that you ’ ve taken the last chapter as the end living! That a man engulfed in the death of Ivan Ilyich ” is full of French.! Appeal, “ this is absolutely the best teacher resource I have purchased!